Federal Gazette & Baltimore Daily Advertiser
1807/01-1807/06

msa_sc3722_2_6_1-0079

   Enlarge and print image (4M)     
 Jump to  
  << PREVIOUS   NEXT >>
clear space clear space clear space white space


 

Federal Gazette & Baltimore Daily Advertiser
1807/01-1807/06

msa_sc3722_2_6_1-0079

   Enlarge and print image (4M)     
 Jump to  
  << PREVIOUS   NEXT >>
I NT DECISION. We I, . for publication the fol- low i- : oftht Snpfeme eotirt de- livered jjy ehief justice Tilghman, on Satin .iv the r;-:J! inst. which settles ihc law .in ]¦'. . :,., on two viery impor- tant points, relative to the right of .aban- donment in cases-of ensiira.'ice. ' -STEMS*) Dut«,H ~) In the Supreme Court X -tjf the state cfP-ennsyl- j •vavia, f?h>!ltia, SxuVEt Gatuff J January 17, 1807. , .-. ic'u for. the opinion of the court. O" the 24th September. 1799 the de- fendant", Samuel Gadiff, underwrote seven hundred and fifty dollars up n a policy of ensurance on the schooner Li'tle Will be- longing to John Dutilh and Thomas Ldli- bridge, f-r whom the plaintiff was agent, » i a voyage at and from Philadelphia to Hrvana, (Front policy.) On the 26th of September, 1799, the Little Will sailed on her voyage from Phi- ladelphia for Havana; and on the eighth day of October following she was captured by three British privateers and carried into the port of Nassau, New.Providence, where she arrived on the thirteenth oi same month. Upon her arrival in Nassau the said schoo- ner was libelled in the admiralty court, and 0' the ninth'day of November following w regularly acquitted ; and in the whole t-sho remained thirty seven days at Nassau, 3u mg thirty five of which she was in cus- ti .. of the captors ; but the fact of her ac- quittal was not known to the plaintiff until after the abandonment hereafter mentioned : although it was known to John-Dutilh, one of the owners and supercargo, who was with her at Nassau. On the thirteenth day of November, the plaintiffwrote the letter of abandonment en- closing the papers therein referred to, (prout letter) which was received by the defendant the same d,ay. On the 2Cth November the said schoo- ner sailed, fiom Nassau for Havana, where she arrived on the 21st of the same month, and sold, her cargo, except three boxes plundered at New-Providence. Afterwards the said schooner sailed from Havana for Philadelphia, where she arrived on the 26th or 27th of February in the year 1800, with a cargo of sugars, on which freight became due and «as received by Stephen Dutilh for the benefit of those who where entitled to it, each party refusing to accept her, she was sold for wharfage, and the whole pro- ceeds cf sale applied to the payment there- ¦ of. The sshooner Little Will was American property as warranted. The qvestion for the court is, whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover as for a tot id loss. If the court shall be of opinion that the loss was total then it shall be referred in the usual form to three persons to be appointed by the court to asceitain what is due after the legal and just deductions. If the court shall be of opinion it was not a total loss, it shall in like manner be referred to three referrets or any two of them to be appointed by the court to ascer- tain the partial loss to which the defendant is liable. J. INGERSOLL, for the Plaintiff. W. LEWIS, for the Defendants July 3d, 1806. Opinion of the court delivered by W. Tilgh- man, C. jf. On the case thus stated tho.qnestion sub- mitted to the court is, whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover for a total loss ? In resolving this question I shall divide it into two points. 1. Did there ever exist a total loss ? vs. Supposing that there once existed a total loss, has any circumstance occurred •which excludes the plaintiff from recovering for more than a partial loss ? I.- The ease before us includes one of tlie risks expressly mentioned in the poli- cy, a taking at sea. But it has been object- ed that this taking was not by an er.emy, and that when a belligerent takes a neutral, it is to be presumed that the taking is only for the purpose of searching for the pro- perty of his enemy) or goods contraband of ¦war, and that in the end, justice will be done to the ncutraj. Toa certain extent there is weight in this distinction ; but it must •rot be carried too far. At the time when the capture in question was made, the U. States acknowledged the right of the Bri- ti.'.h to detain their vessels for the purpose of a reas< nable search. The bare taking of the vessel-, therefore, could by no means constitute a loss ; and if under suspicious circumstances, she should be carried into port to afford an opportunity f..r a complete investigation, perhaps even that ought not c.f itself to be considered as a total loss. On this, however, I give no opinion. But when the captor, having carried the ves- sel into port, and completed the ex- •wirnaficn of the cargo and papers, in- stead of discharging her, proceeds to libel iicr as prize, 1 think the loss is complete. The property is no longer subject to the Command of (he owner, and it is unrea- sonable that he should wait the event of judicial proceedings, which may continue for x^ars. The "case of an embargo 1 1-^ o ess strong—because there the confiscation ot the property is not intended, and a tem- porary interruption of the voyage is all th.it in general is to be apprehended. Yet the assured is not obliged to v.ait the re- sult, but may abandon immediately on re- ceipt of intelligence of (he embargo. Not many judicial decisions have been produc- ed oii the point'in question. Where prin- have been no decisions to the contrary. It appears, however, that in the state of New-York, the precise point has been de- termined. In the case of Mum ford vs. Church, decided in the supreme court of N. York, July term, 1799, the assured re- covered far a total loss where there was a captor, carrying, into port, and libelling by a British captor, although after the abandonment the property was res- tored. It is necessary that some general rule should be established ; some line drawn, by vvhich the assured may know at what time he has a right to abandon. In most cases the voya,.;a is extremely injured by proceedings in the court of admiralty, and the event is d .ubtful. For it cannot be de- nied, that of late years such extraordinary occurrences have taken place in war and politics as have very much affected the prin- ciples and practice of foreign courts of ad- miralty. Whatever maybe said of the law of nature and nations and the immutable principles of justice, we see very plainly that the courts obey the will of the sove- reign power of their country ; and this will fluctuates with the circumstances of the times. I am therefore of opinion, that both by the words and spirit of a policy of ensurance, the assured may abandon when he receives intelligence of the libelling of his vessel. 2. This brings rne to the consideration of the second point. Has any circumstance occurred " which limits the plaintiff to a re- covery for only a partial loss :" It is contended, that such an event has occurred : that the vessel was acquitted by decree of the court of admiralty ; that after acquittal she proceeded on her voyage, and that one of the owners was on the spot and knew of the acquittal. I do not think there is much weight in the circumstance of one of the owners being on the spot ; because the general agent of all the owners was in Philadelphia. This general agent effected the insurance, & conducted all the business with the underwriters, and the owner who was in New-Providence, gave him intelli- gence of what occurred from time to time, and by no means intended, from any thing that appears, to restrain him from making an abandonment. It is true that the vessel proceeded on her voyage after she was res- tored : but it is not stated, nor can the court presume, that any of the owners acted in a manner inconsistent with the abandonment made by their agent. It was proper, at all events, to pursue the voyage for the benefit of whoever might be interested in it. This is the usual practice, and a practice" autho- rized by the policy, and very much for the advantage of the underwriters. The only difficulty in the case before the ¦court arises from this cirenmstanee; that be- fore the action was brought, the vessel was restored, and even at the time of the aban- donment, there was a decree of acquittal, al- though restitution does not appear to have been actually made till some days after. The counsel for the defendant have relied much on the opinion of lord Mansfield in the case of Hamilton v. Mendez, to estab'ish this principle, that a policy of insurance, being in its nature a contract, of indemnity, the plaintiff can -recover no more than the a- mount of his actual loss at the commence- ment of the action. There is no doubt of the soundness of the principle : I mean that a policy is a contract of indemnity. The only question is, at -what period the rights bf.the parties are to be tested by this princi- ple ; whether at the time of abandonment or of the commencement of the action. I have considered attentively the case of Ha- milton -v. Mendez. It must be obvious to every one that the decision in that case was perfectly right. It was simply this ; that a man shall not be permitted to abandon, and recover for a total loss, when he knew at the time of his offer to abandon, that his pro- perty which had been lost, was restored, and the voyage very little injured. But in reading the opinion of lord Mansfield we find a want of accuracy with which that great man was seldom chargeable. Some times it appears as if he thought the period for fixing the rights of the insurers and in- sured was the commencement of the suit; sometimes the tune of abandonment ; and sometimes he even seems to extend his ideas so Jar as the time of the verdict. But final- ly, he explicitly declares, that he decides nothing but the point; before him. He seems to have felr a little sore at the improper ap- plication of some general expressions used by him in the case cri" Goss vs. Withers. Anxious to cut off all pretence for doing the same in Hamilton vs. Mendez, he has taken too much pains to avoid the possibility of misrepresentation. Henee his argument con- sidered in the whole is not altogether clear and consistent. Upon the whole of this case of Hamilton vs. Mendez, I think it most safe to confine its authority to the point actually decided, which was very dif- ferent from that we are now considering. Some period must be fixed for determining the right of the parties. Tv limit it to the time 0/ cnnKn ncing the action would be of little service to the ensure rs ; for the Jaw be- ing once so established, un action would be brought in e\my instance on the first default of payment. The time of abandonment seems the most natural and convenient peri- od ; because the assured must make his election to abandon or not, in a reasonable and short time after he hear* of the loss, and the property, being transferred by the abandonment, can never after be reclaimed by the assured. Want of mutuality is want of justice. There is no reason why the as- sured should be bound, but the assurer left free to take advantage of events subsequent to the abandodmeiit. It has been contended by the plaintiff's counsel, that the right to abandon would not have been affected, even if the property had been restored at the time of abandon- ment, because the restitution was unknown to the plaintiff. As to this, I give no opini- on. It is unnecessary; because it is stated that the vessel remained in the custody of the captors, at; tbg time of the abandon- ment. The defei dart's counsel have urged that this was the fault of the captain, or of one of the owners who was then at New- Providence ; because after a decree of ac- quittal, a -writ of restitution might have been sued-out. But it not being stated that there was any fault or negligence in die captain or owner, I do npt think; that the vessel remained in the custody of the cap. tors, we must presume that the custody was legal—Whether for the purpose of giving ptors an opportunity of entering .an appeal, or fof what purpose it was the resti- tution was delayed, we are at a loss to deter- mine. But, as restitution was not actually made, and as the . plaintiff was ignorant, even of the decree of acquittal, his right to abandon remained unimpaired. Upon the whole, I am of opinion that the plaintiff is entitled to recover for a total toss. From the (N. Y.) Evenkig Pest. Mr. Editor, I observed in your paper of Saturday evening, an account of a telegraph lately in- vented by Mr. Edward Pierce, of Charleston, which is much commended for itssiinplicity. It appears to me, however, that his machine is more complicated than is necessary ; and that a plan for the construction of a tele- graph which has suggested itself to me on reading the communication from Mr. Pierce, will be more simple and useful than his in- vention. My telegraph should consist of five boards painted black, set on\a line with their faces towards the quarter to which I would com- municate intelligence. Two of them should be a little separated from the others. The first of these boards, that is, the one on the left hand as I looked towards them, should have two holes or spaces cut out about the size of a common pain of glass. And each of the other boardsshould have nine like spaces. The spaces should have little doors that might be quickly opened and shut by simple ma- chinery. The last board to the right hand should be a board of units, the next of tens. The next board should again be a board of units, the next of tens, and the next of hun- dreds. And the number of spaces open in each board, should express respectively so many units, tens and hundreds. So if one space in each board was open, the Tele- graph would express the two numbers or Sum* 111 and 11 ; if all th&spaees were o- pen, 299 and 97 would ft expressed. I should never want to useTiigher numbers than these. And I would ntake these num- bers and the inferior ones subservient to ev- ery purpose in this way. I would have a dictionary page and each word in every page numbered. The person with whom I would communicate should have a dictionary page and numbered so as to cor- respond exactly with mine. So that when the Telegraph expressed certain numbers, they would refer to the same word in both dictionaries. . The first three boards would designate the page, the two last the number of the word. I have now before me a small pocket diction- ary, which I find contains 222 pages, and 81} words to a page. Now suppose I wished to communicate the word " abandonment," which I find to be the 9th word in the first page of the dictionary, my Telegraph would stand thus: the last or right hand board would have all the spaces open, and thus would be expressed the first page and ninth word. The advantages that my Telegraph would have over that proposed by Mr. Pierce, is that the signals or signs, could be observed at a much greater distance than his letters and figures and balls could be. I have seen a common Venetian window blind, which happened to be so placed as that there was nothing to interrupt the light on either side 5 and it is inconceivable at what a dis- tance you could tell whether the blind was turned so as to abstruct the light, or left as open as possible.—Again, such a Telegraph as I propose might be worked with much more facility and expedition than one on the other construction. If made to move ac- cording to a plan I have had in my mind, whether one or nine, or more or less spaces were to be opened in each board, it could be done with a single motion. And my tele- graph would have this decided advantage, that with the addition of lamps behind the open spaces, it would answer better by night than by dayr. But there is no saying how simple a con- trivano* may be the means of communicat- ing intelligence with the assistance of num- bers and dictionaries. Since I have com- menced writing this communication another plan has occurred to me which I think would be still more simple and useful. With only two poles, such as our signal poles on Staten-Island; and one small cross piece to each, to be moved with the hand without any rope or pully or other machinery, I think intelligence might be communicated nearly as fast as it could be printed. If I find that this subject excites any curi- osity, and if I should not on reflection dis- cover objections to the last plan I have men- tioned, which are now unforeseen, it shall be communicated for your paper, by your humble servant, NEDLOE. BOULOGNE, October 14. An English division, of 31 sail, drew near Boulogne, the 9th of this month, to repeat Its incendiary attempts. During the night, the division threw about a hundred incendiary rockets into the port and town, a n§w invented means, which has not proved more successful than jill those which the enemy had tried against the flotilla. These rockets are made of an iron cy- linder, about four inches diameter (two feet and a half long) terminating by a very sharp cone, 8 inches long. The hollow is filled with combustible mat- ter, the flame of which issues through the upper orifice and through holes in the body of the cylinder and the cone at the bot- tom. The interior extremity of the cone ap- pears intended to fix the machine upon the object it strikes. Be it as it may, the greater number of these rockets proved ineffectual. Two fell upon ships, and were extinguished without difficulty, and without the ships receiving the slightest damage. A house which served as a store for fag- gots, was set on fire, because, nobody be- ing in it, assistance could not be had time enongh to stop the effect of a rocket which had fallen among the faggots. The next day a great many of th.ese machines, vvhich had not been made use of, were found, upon the strand, at low water. / able* Hint the Boat IacTen with them, was sunk by the fire cf the batteries. In the night of the I.oth, the enemy re- commenced a fresh bombardment, which had >no other effect than to wound, by a splinter a young man of 14 years of age. Every measure had been previously ta- ken to remedy any accident that might hap- pen. The batteries kept up a fire upon the enemy, which soon obliged them to sheer off. It was the same case at Calais, in the night of the 13th. Several bombs were thrown against the town, without causing the least damage, and the batteries in less than two hours forced the enemy to ouit the coast. Thus the incendiary rockets have miscar- ried this year, in the same manner as did last year the bombs, globes with three ori- fices, submerged fire-ships, trigger machines, and all the other infernal contrivances which England has addopted the use of. But what has been singular upon this last occasion, is that the enemy should have chos- en for a new trial to burn the ports of Bou- logne and Calais, the very moment when lord Lauderdale was to be in one or other of them. In fact, he arrived the nth at Boulogne, a few hours before the end of the last bom- bardment. Every measure was taken to spare him the pain of perceiving the exas- peration of an indignant people. That mi- nister, having desired to rest himself in the town, slept at the hou'se of the commandant of the flotilla, and the 12th, in the morning was conveyed on board of an English fri- gate- England will doubtless learn from lord Lauderdale how much the behavior he ex- perienced at Boulogne, contrasts with the animosity of which this town had again just experienced the effects, ever incindia- ary, but ever impotent. [Moniteur] BY'. THIS BAY's MAILS. FIFTEENTH BULLETIN. Wittemberg, 23d October, 1806. The following is the information we have been able to collect on the causes of this strange war. General Schmettau (died a prisoner at Weimar) drew up a memorial, written with much energy, in which he proved, that the Prussian army in its inac- tive situation ought jo look upon itself as dishonored ; that it was nevertheless in a si- tuation to beat the French, and that'war ought to be declared. The generals Huchcl (dead) and Blucher (who only saved him- self by a subterfuge in abusing the good faith of the French) subscribed this memo- rial; which was drawn up in the form of a petition to the king. Prince Louis of Prus- sia (killed) supported it with all kind of sarcasms ; the rage took possession of all heads ; the duke of Brunswick (severely wounded) a man known to be without a will of his own, and without character, was en- rolled in the war faction ; in a word, the memorial thus supported, was presented to the king. The queen took upon herself to dispose the mind of tins prince, and to let him'know what was thought of him ; she told him that it was said he w.is not bra.-e, and that he did not make war because-hewas afraid to put himself at the head of his ar- my. The king, wlio is as really brave as any Prussian prince, has suffered himself to be drawn Into the vortex without ceasing to preserve the 1 pinion that lie was commit- ting a great fault. We must now point out the men wdio did not partake of the illusions of the partisans of war ; these are the res- pectable field-marshal Moilendorf, and gene- ral Kalkreuth. We are assured, that after the handsome charge made by the 9th and 10th regiments of hussars at Saalfeld, the king said, "you pretend that the French cavalry is of no va- lue ; s*e, nevertheless, what the light caval- ry lias done, andjudgewh.it the cuirassiers will do. These troops have acquired their superiority by fifteen years of combats ; it- will require as long a time to equal them ; but who of us is so equal an enemy to Prus- sia as to desire this terrible proof ?" The emperor, already master of all the communications and magazines of the ene- my, wrote on the 12th of this month, the letter here joined, which he sent to the king of Prussia, by the officer of ordonance, Montesquieu- This officer arrived the 13th at 4 o'clock in the afternoon, at the head quarters of Hohenlohe, who retained him with him, and took the letter of which he was the bearer. The camp of the king of Prussia was two leagues in rear. This prince ought then to have received the let- ter of the emperor at the latest at 6 o'clock; we are assured, nevertheless, that he did not receive it until nine o'clock in the morning of the 14th, that is to say, after the fighting- was begun. It is reported also, that the king of Prussia said then, " If this letter had arrived sooner, perhaps there would have been no occasion for a battle ; but these young people have their heads so high, that if their had been a question yesterday of peace, I should not have been, able to take back one third of my army to Berlin." The king of Prussia had two horses killed under him, and received a wound from a musket in the arm. All the mistakes of of this warare due to the duke of Brunswick ; he misconceived and badly directed the movements of the army ; he believed that the emperor was at Paris, when he found him 111 his flanks ; he thought he possessed a knowledge of all the movements, and he was already turned. On the evening before the battle, consterna- tion had taken place amongst the chiefs. They discovered thai they were badly post- ed, and their play was to be for the whole of the monarchy. They all said, '' ah ! well, we shall pay for it with our persons 5" which is commonly the sentiment of men who retain little hope. The queen remain- ed constantly at head-quarters at Weymar ; it became necessary to tell her at last, that circumstances became serious, the next day great ; for the Prussian monarchy ;—she that the king should tell her tc depart ; she was shortly after prepared f r setting out. Lord Morpeth scat by tlie court of L v don to merchandize for Prussian blood, h sion truly unworthy of a man like him, ar- rived on the nth at Weymar, charged L> make seducing offers and to propose consi- derable subsidies The horizon was already sufficient obscured ; the cabinet would see'this envoy, but made known that per- haps there was little safety for his person, and advised him to return to Hamburg, and there wait events. What would the • dutches* of Devonshire have said it she h id seen her relative charged with the busind.'* of blowing up the flame of war, with baa- ing come to offer empoisoned gold and be obliged to return disconsolate on his steps and in great haste ? We cannot but be in- dignant at seeing England compromit the fate of estimable agents and play so odious a part. We have no accounts yet of the conclusi- on of a treaty between Prussia and Russia, and it is certain that not a single Russian to this day has appeared on the Prussian territory ; however, the army is very ailxi ous to see them—-they will find an Auster litz in Prussia. Prince Louis Ferdinand, of Prussia, an' the other generals who have fallen under the first blows of the French, are at t day pointed out as the principal movers < this incredible frenKy. The king, wl runs all risques, and supports all the mi fortiines which have resulted, is of all lhef» I men who have been drawn intoit, he who I was most a stranger to it. There is at Leipzic such a quantity of English merchandize, that they have already offered sixty millions to redeem it. We will ask what will England gain by- all this ? She might have recovered Hano- ver, kept the Cape of Good Hope, preserv- ed Malta, made an honorable peace, and restored tranquility to the world. But she chose to excite Prussia against France, and wished to circumscribe the emperor anjd France. Ah well ! she has led Prussia to ruiu ; I procured greater glory for the emperor, 40 France greater power, and the time ap- proaches when they will declare England1 . in a state of continental blockade. Is it then with blood diat the English have hoped to aliment their commerce and re-animate their industry ? Great misfortunes may fall upon England, and Europe will attribute them to the loss of that honest minister who wished to govern by great and liberal ideas, and whom the English people will weep over one day with tears of blood. The French columns march already on Potsdam and Berlin, deputies from Potsdam have arrived to ask for a safe guard. The imperial quarters are this day at Wittemberg. NEW-YORK, Jan. 21. The paragraphs which have appeared in tliis Gagette relative to a duel were founded on common report. We are now convinc- ed, from a more correct source, that what we have gazetted on this subject, was erro- neous, v , Arrived, the brig Rockland) Kitchen, 13 days from Charleston. January 36 the brig Louisa, from Charleston, for jRhc ' Island. Same day, the brig George, Low, of Boston, 60 days from Surriiiam, havitg en board a Virginia pilot, blown off tj !« Capes, sails in bad condition-captain K. gave a supply of beef, candles, &c. The brig Olive Branch., Lumsden, 22 days from St. Pierres, (Mart.) Left stand- ing off and on, the brig Julia-Ann, 16 day* from New-York ; brig------, Allen, just ar- rived from New-London, and others before reported. January 13, Int. 86, long 74, spoke a ship 73 days from Bordeaux for Phi- ladelphia. The brig Merchant, Carson, from Bona- vista, and 29 days from Barbados. Lt ft at Bonavista, ship Magnet, of New-York ; schr. Ann-Gardner, Murray, of Hudson, with salt from Bonavista, and others. J n, 10, lat. 34, long. 74, spoke brig Mary, 4- days from Philadelphia) for New-Oil- ms. The schr. Traveller, Reading, '"2 days from St. Pierres, (Mart.) Left brig Clothier, Coffin, for New-York, wailing for freight ; brig Virginia, discharging. December 27, off Dominique was bearded by a British fri- gate and strictly examined—another frigi:e in company. The schr. Mariner, Gale, 49 days front 1 urracoa. Cleared, ship Susan, Howard, jnn. Charles- ton ; General Clarksoit, Conkliu, Amster- dam ; Louisiana, Pelor, Savannah ; brig Aurora, Miller, Havanna ; Bedford, Dun- bar, Liverpool : Sea-Island, lUirnhnm, Sa- vannah ; schr. Lovely Lass, Rogers, Ja- maica ; Active, Bass, Liverpool. We are informed, that by an accident . which took place during the representation of Mr. Martin's Phantasmagoria, the Mu- seum at Boston was burnt down on Friday evening, and several lives were lost. We do not learn that any of the contiguous bud- dings were injured. The brig Venus, Hildreth, from Charles- ton, was driven ashore by the ice on Mon- day night upon Long-Island, opposite Cor- ker's Hook. Part of her cargo is discharg- ed. Monday afternoon the brig Eliza, lying at the end of Jones's wharf, coflee-house slip, had a hole cut in her side by the float- ing ice, which the severe cold has filled our rivers with, and sunk. CHARLESTON, Jan. 9. Arrived, brig Mount Vernon, Williams, Cadiz 40, days ; brig Flora, Shaw, Nas- sau 10 ; schr. Regulator, Crowell, Bos- ton 15. Cleared, ship Susan, Stevens, Liverpool; brig BtUona, Laf!6n, Havana ; schr.